Nancy Guthrie Probe Slammed as Pizza Delivery Sparks Crime Scene Controversy
The investigation into the disappearance of 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie, mother of 'Today' show host Savannah Guthrie, has been heavily criticized by former Pima County Sheriff Dr. Richard Carmona. He slammed the current sheriff's office, stating the case has been 'complicated' by its handling, and specifically pointed to a pizza delivery to the crime scene as a catastrophic error that potentially corrupted evidence. 'If you’re going to court... a defense attorney says, ‘That crime scene was corrupted—you had people delivering pizzas,’' Carmona stated, adding, 'Once it has been corrupted, that’s the end of it.' This criticism has intensified pressure on current Sheriff Chris Nanos, who is also facing a no-confidence vote and has defended his department's management of the case. The controversy deepened with the arrest of a deputy, though sources confirm he is not linked to the kidnapping, and online speculation has compared his appearance to masked footage from Guthrie's doorbell camera. Simultaneously, the discovery of a woman's body in a Scottsdale canal has added a grim new dimension to the ongoing search, though an official identification is pending. Adding to the complex narrative, true crime commentator Nancy Grace has entered the fray, demanding the death penalty and asserting her belief that multiple people were involved in the abduction, suggesting 'somebody could crack.' The case has also spawned strange details, including police warnings about related scams and mysterious helicopter flights between Tucson, the Mexican border, and an FBI site in Phoenix, fueling further speculation about a potential cross-border element to the investigation.
Prefer swipe-first reading?
Install the app to keep reading with faster loads and a smoother mobile experience.
Sources
Fact Check: Was a deputy linked to the Nancy Guthrie probe arrested in her kidnapping case?
Despite there being no confirmed link, the arrest has generated significant online attention. A photo of Reynolds has been released, and some people are comparing his appearance to the masked person seen in footage from Nancy Guthrie’s doorbell camera. ... GET BREAKING U.S. NEWS & POLITICAL ...
Nancy Guthrie Case Latest Update: How Pizza Delivery Sparks Crime Scene Controversy, Ex-Sheriff Slams ‘Corrupted’ Probe as Woman’s Body Found in Arizona Canal
Check out other tags: ArizonaArizona ... caseNancy Guthrie missing casepizza delivery incidentpolice probeSavannah GuthrieScottsdale canalsheriff criticismsheriff investigationTucson investigationUS crime news · Nancy Guthrie Case Latest Update: How Pizza Delivery Sparks Crime Scene ...
Nancy Guthrie: Was crime scene corrupted? Bombshell claim emerges as Pima County sheriff faces a no-confidence vote | Hindustan Times
Carmona further questioned delivery ... of the probe. “If you’re going to court and you’re making a case, a defense attorney says, ‘That crime scene was corrupted—you had people delivering pizzas,'” the former Sheriff said. “‘How do we know this is real evidence?'” · He went on to say, “Once it has been corrupted, that’s the end of it.” · Meanwhile, Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos stood by his department's management of the Nancy Guthrie case during ...
nancy guthrie update: Savannah Guthrie mother Nancy Guthrie missing case probe day 53 big find latest update: Savannah Guthrie interview, plea, police scam warning, Today show host return status and investigation details - The Economic Times
Savannah Guthrie mother Nancy Guthrie missing case probe day 53 big find latest update shows the investigation continues with no arrests. Family shares emotional interview, police warn about scams, and key clues including footage and timelines remain under review as search efforts continue.
Nancy Grace Is Convinced 'There's More Than One' Suspect in Nancy Guthrie's Disappearance: 'Somebody Could Crack' - AOL
Multiple people were likely involved in the abduction of Today star Savannah Guthrie's missing mom, according to prominent true crime television personality Nancy Grace. During an appearance on the Thursday, March 26, broadcast of Sean Hannity's show, Grace, 66, and the Fox News host discussed ...
Fact Checks
Related news
Secretary of State Marco Rubio Signals Potential Breakthrough in Iran Nuclear Talks
Secretary of State Marco Rubio announced during a Senate budget hearing that Iran has agreed to negotiate aspects of its nuclear program. While Rubio signaled a potential breakthrough in peace talks, he emphasized that the Trump administration requires Iran to accept severe nuclear limits as a prerequisite for any deal. Rubio clarified that the U.S. has not offered sanctions relief in exchange for reopening the Strait of Hormuz, insisting that such relief is tied strictly to the dismantling of Tehran's nuclear capabilities. Despite the preference for a negotiated settlement, Rubio warned that other options remain available should diplomacy fail.
Trump Demands Written Nuclear Commitments as Iran Deal Negotiations Stall
President Donald Trump has sent a revised draft of a proposed agreement with Iran back for amendments, demanding that Tehran provide specific, written commitments to prevent the acquisition of nuclear weapons. Despite previous verbal assurances from Iranian officials, Trump has insisted on tougher language and conditions regarding the reopening of the Strait of Hormuz before lifting naval blockades. While the administration claims talks are moving rapidly, reports suggest a more volatile situation. Some sources indicate that Iran has paused negotiations amid regional clashes, and critics point to contradictory statements from the White House regarding the stability of the diplomatic efforts as a nominal ceasefire continues to be tested by sporadic attacks.
White House Correspondents' Dinner Rescheduled for July 24 Following Shooting
The White House Correspondents' Association (WHCA) will hold its annual dinner on July 24, nearly three months after the original April 25 event was halted by a shooting. WHCA President Weijia Jiang announced the rescheduled date, noting that the event will feature significantly enhanced security and a different ballroom location to ensure safety. President Donald Trump and First Lady Melania Trump, who were rushed from the scene during the initial attack, are expected to attend. While the WHCA frames the event as a celebration of press freedom, some advocates have expressed concern that the gathering could provide the President with a platform to attack the media.
US Military Disables Oil Tanker Bound for Iran in Strait of Hormuz
US Central Command (CENTCOM) reported that a US aircraft fired a Hellfire missile into the engine room of the Botswana-flagged M/T Lexie on Tuesday. The vessel was targeted in international waters while sailing toward Kharg Island after the crew allegedly ignored repeated warnings and failed to comply with American instructions. This marks the sixth commercial vessel disabled by US forces since the implementation of the naval blockade along the Strait of Hormuz. The strike occurs amid a broader escalation involving attacks on sites on Qeshm Island and US defensive operations in Kuwait and Bahrain. The ongoing blockade has caused significant maritime disruption, leaving approximately 20,000 seafarers trapped in the war zone and prompting urgent discussions among global shipping executives…
North Carolina Valedictorian Interrupted During Graduation Speech Over Unscripted Remarks
Leen Hijaz, the valedictorian of Clayton High School in North Carolina, was interrupted and removed from the stage by school officials during her graduation ceremony on May 28. The intervention occurred after Hijaz deviated from her pre-approved script to make unscripted remarks regarding ICE and Palestine. Following the incident, Hijaz claimed her diploma was initially withheld, though Johnston County Schools later confirmed she has since received it. The incident has drawn polarized reactions online. Some critics praised the principal for stopping what they described as a political hijacking of the ceremony, while others argued the school's attempt to silence the student only served to amplify her message. The viral video of the encounter has fueled a broader national debate over…
Secretary of State Marco Rubio Says Iran's Supreme Leader Mojtaba Khamenei is Alive
Secretary of State Marco Rubio informed the Senate Foreign Relations Committee on Tuesday that there are indications Iran's Supreme Leader, Mojtaba Khamenei, is alive and increasingly engaged in governing. Rubio noted that Khamenei is communicating through written messages and intermediaries, signaling an active role in the country's leadership. This update comes amid high regional tensions and ongoing nuclear negotiations, where the U.S. suggests a deal for sanctions relief in exchange for nuclear limits may be within reach. The confirmation follows reports that Khamenei was injured during U.S.-Israeli airstrikes on Tehran on February 28, raising previous questions about the stability of Iran's leadership.
Take Yomuyo with you
Download the mobile app for personalized headlines and quick access to breaking stories.